Sherlock BBC

[Lilasko]

Originally Posted by Dreamy_Queen

Ah, sorry... I don't remember the English text exactly. And Reichenbach I watched only 2 times, too sad.

Well I didn't remember it at all so I had to use google I've only watched the episode once so that's probably why.

I noticed something I think is very important if you want to know how Sherlock faked his own death. Maybe everyone already knows this, but the person who jumps is wearing a white shirt but the person that's laying on the ground is wearing a black shirt. So they are not the same persons.

I feel kind a proud that I figured that one out by myself, so please don't say that you already knew that and I'm way behind as usually.

[Dreamy_Queen]

Originally Posted by Lilasko

Well I didn't remember it at all so I had to use google I've only watched the episode once so that's probably why.

I noticed something I think is very important if you want to know how Sherlock faked his own death. Maybe everyone already knows this, but the person who jumps is wearing a white shirt but the person that's laying on the ground is wearing a black shirt. So they are not the same persons.

I feel kind a proud that I figured that one out by myself, so please don't say that you already knew that and I'm way behind as usually.

I haven't noticed it. But anyway, the one who was laying was definitely Benedict, so even if it was not Sherlock, it can't be anyone else..
http://sc.aithine.org/sherlock/203/2...-203-24816.jpg
He can't use any mask of himself...It is not a smart way for Moffat!
Wait, Sherlock on the roof had the same colour of shirt:
http://sc.aithine.org/sherlock/203/2...-203-24048.jpg

So maybe this was not a shirt? It is white only at waist...
http://sc.aithine.org/sherlock/203/2...-203-24358.jpg

I don't know, what do you think?

[Lilasko]

Originally Posted by Dreamy_Queen

Co-Creator Live Chats: Steven Moffat

Sherlock co-creator Steven Moffat chats with fans about season 2 of the hit series, the dramatic conclusion of episode three, The Reichenbach Fall, and more.

Join the live, online chat on Monday, May 21, 2012, at 1pm Eastern time, or return after the chat to read the complete transcript.
Here:

http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/masterpiece/...at_moffat.html


and
Co-Creator Live Chats: Mark Gatiss
Sherlock co-creator and star Mark Gatiss chats with fans about season 2 of the hit series, writing The Hounds of Baskerville, and the dubious distinction of being a part of Sherlock's family tree, portraying brother Mycroft in the series.

Join the live, online chat on Monday, May 14, 2012, at 1pm Eastern time, or return after the chat to read the complete transcript.

http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/masterpiece/...at_gatiss.html

Yay!
Will definitely try to ask some questions. But do you know which time it is in CET?

[Dreamy_Queen]

Originally Posted by Lilasko

Yay!
Will definitely try to ask some questions. But do you know which time it is in CET?

Have no idea...
I'm bad at maths, but it seems like 1 PM will be 8 PM in Europe. But I'm not sure.

[Dreamy_Queen]

Sir Arthur Ignatius Conan Doyle has a birthday today!!! He was born 22 May 1859, and today he would be 153 !

[Julia Welcomes]

DQ, you should be the Mod of this thread. You`re always in time !

Sir Arthur would be proud of you

[Dreamy_Queen]

Originally Posted by Julia Welcomes

DQ, you should be the Mod of this thread. You`re always in time !

Sir Arthur would be proud of you

I am *modestly*

[Lilasko]

Originally Posted by Dreamy_Queen

I haven't noticed it. But anyway, the one who was laying was definitely Benedict, so even if it was not Sherlock, it can't be anyone else..
http://sc.aithine.org/sherlock/203/2...-203-24816.jpg
He can't use any mask of himself...It is not a smart way for Moffat!
Wait, Sherlock on the roof had the same colour of shirt:
http://sc.aithine.org/sherlock/203/2...-203-24048.jpg

So maybe this was not a shirt? It is white only at waist...
http://sc.aithine.org/sherlock/203/2...-203-24358.jpg

I don't know, what do you think?

I thought so to, but if you turn the picture of him laying on the ground it doesn't look like him. But I don't know if it's because it isn't Sherlock or because it's a wired angle.
So my thought was, it's Sherlock at the roof. Then it's somebody else that's jumping and then it is Sherlock that is laying on the ground. But then, who is jumping?
So maybe it's just nothing, just a simple T-shirt that Sherlock is wearing under his shirt?

I've read too many "how Sherlock faked his own death" theories, so I don't know what to think anymore...

All I want is that the theories I've read so far won't be true. Because I think they're too simple. I'm hoping for something really brilliant. Steven Moffat said that the way Sherlock faked his own death was clever, so I want it too be mind blowing.

[Dreamy_Queen]

There is a transcript of yesterday's chat with Moffat.

http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/masterpiece/...at_moffat.html

Here, here!

Q: Were Sherlock's tears in Reichenbach real?

Steven Moffat: He's Sherlock Holmes, he knew exactly what he was doing. Sentimentalise him at your peril.




Q: What are the chances of Moriarty coming back from the dead? Andrew Scott has been amazing in the role.

Steven Moffat: Did you SEE all that blood???

[Lilasko]

Originally Posted by Dreamy_Queen

Sir Arthur Ignatius Conan Doyle has a birthday today!!! He was born 22 May 1859, and today he would be 153 !

Congratulations Sir Arthur Ignatius Conan Doyle!
Too bad you don't live so you can see this new absolutely brilliant series of your books, Sherlock!

[Dreamy_Queen]

Originally Posted by Lilasko

I thought so to, but if you turn the picture of him laying on the ground it doesn't look like him. But I don't know if it's because it isn't Sherlock or because it's a wired angle.
So my thought was, it's Sherlock at the roof. Then it's somebody else that's jumping and then it is Sherlock that is laying on the ground. But then, who is jumping?
So maybe it's just nothing, just a simple T-shirt that Sherlock is wearing under his shirt?

I've read too many "how Sherlock faked his own death" theories, so I don't know what to think anymore...

All I want is that the theories I've read so far won't be true. Because I think they're too simple. I'm hoping for something really brilliant. Steven Moffat said that the way Sherlock faked his own death was clever, so I want it too be mind blowing.

I suppose it was definitely Sherlock, because I will recognize Benedict's lips anywhere
And from the roof jumped - ta da! - a stuntman I think that's why everybody are puzzled. Ben jumped only to the smaller place (not roof, I don't know how to call it), and there was a stuntman who jumped more dangerously.

[Lilasko]

So what do you guys think of this new American Sherlock series, Elementary?

A modern take on the cases of Sherlock Holmes, with the detective now living in New York City. In Elementary, Holmes is a former consultant to Scotland Yard. Holmes is an addict who travels to New York City to check into a rehabilitation center and stays on in Brooklyn with a newly-found sober companion Joan Watson.
You heard right John Watson is a female.

After I've watched the clip I just felt like they are trying to do an American rip off of BBC's Sherlock, and I don't like it. Sherlock feels out of character, too young, too naive, too human and it feels like he's trying to act someone he's not. Like at 2:10 He doesn't feel exited, more like he's trying to act exited. Actually I think Joan Watson outshines Sherlock, and then something is wrong...

Elementary feels more like if Gregory House (if you seen House) would have started a detective bureau and casted a hot women as his sidekick, more than if the real Sherlock would have moved to NY (why would he move NY in the first place?) But I'm going to give Elementary a chance, but I don't think it will ever be as great as BBc's Sherlock.