I apologize if it's been already said, Ive only read the 1st and last page of the topic.
I don't think you can really hold against Mika the fact that he tells the same stories at the gigs. I dont think it has to do with experience, it has more to do with trying to put the best show possible. When he sees that one of his comments/story works with the audience, he is going to repeat it more, it's probably safer but at the same time he is sure that its not going to fall flat.
You also have remember that 90% of the audience are gonna see the concert just once, so they'll never know that the story has been told 10 times already!!
I have been to only 2 Mika concerts, so I cant really tell if I would get bored hearing the same thing a few times.
However i have been to quite a few U2 shows on their last tour and Ive listened to many bootlegs, and even though Bono has almost 30 years of stage experience and is great public speaker, he is gonna tell the same stories over and over again. It doesnt take away from their performance because even if u have heard the story already, you still enjoy it because its told a bit differently every night and its great to see the crowd reaction.
As fans we would like to hear different stories, different songs (although Mika has only 1 album, he could do more covers...), I guess his ultimate goal is to put on the perfect show to build his reputation.
On the radio 1 interview earlier today, he talked about doing some acoustic shows, more intimate, that's probably where he'll be able to take more risk and perform different songs, tell new stories every night...
I hope he does that soon!! although tickets will probably be difficult to get!!
anywayssss, just my 2cents.